Mpumalanga Mother And Baby Awarded R300,000 After 3 Days In Police Cells

Mpumalanga Mother And Baby Win R300,000 After 3 Days In Police Cells

A Mpumalanga mother and her six-month-old baby have been awarded a combined R300,000 after the Mpumalanga High Court found that they were unlawfully arrested and detained in police cells for almost three days.

The ruling, delivered by Acting Judge H.F. Fourie, ordered the Minister of Police to pay the mother and child R150,000 each (approximately US$8,970 or about R150,000 each) after finding there was no legal justification for their detention. The incident stemmed from a domestic violence dispute on 8 March 2024.

Mpumalanga High Court Finds Arrest And Detention Were Unlawful

The woman told the court she was arrested at about 11pm after a domestic violence incident involving the father of her child. Police instructed her to collect clothes and blankets because her six-month-old baby would accompany her to the police station.

premier

She and her baby remained in police cells from around 2am on 9 March 2024 until approximately 2pm on 11 March 2024. She was then taken to court and released without standing trial or facing criminal charges.

The publication IOL reports that the Minister of Police did not defend the matter. Although the State Attorney reportedly attempted to contact the woman’s legal representatives on the hearing date, neither the Minister nor legal representatives appeared before court or requested a postponement.

Acting Judge Fourie proceeded with the hearing after finding the matter was undefended.

“Every arrest and detention is presumed to be unlawful unless the State can justify it.”

Judge Raises Concerns Over Six-Month-Old Baby Being Held In Cells

The mother testified that the holding cells were dirty and unhygienic. She said detainees were given filthy blankets and that she shared the cell with another mother and child, together with two other detainees at one stage.

The judge accepted her evidence because it was not challenged.

In his judgment, Acting Judge Fourie stressed that children enjoy special constitutional protection and that detention should only ever be used as a last resort.

“The detention of this young child was not a last resort but seems to have been standard practice.”

The judge noted that another mother and child had also been detained under similar circumstances.

Court Orders Compensation For Mother And Child

When determining compensation, the court considered previous unlawful arrest cases and said damages should compensate victims for violations of their constitutional rights rather than enrich them.

The court awarded the mother R150,000 (approximately US$8,970) and awarded a further R150,000 (approximately US$8,970) to the child. The child’s compensation will be placed into a trust established for the child’s sole benefit until it becomes operational.

The judgment also acknowledged that no financial award can fully compensate someone for the loss of personal freedom.

The ruling reinforces the legal principle that police must justify every arrest and detention. It also highlights the constitutional protections afforded to children, particularly where deprivation of liberty is concerned.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *